Scott Caldwell
Trial Attorney, AP Injury Lawyers
20 years of practice and more than 10 jury trials tried to verdict.
Scott Caldwell is a trial attorney at AP Injury Lawyers, bringing 20 years of practice to injured people in Oklahoma City. He spent about 10 years as defense counsel for Allstate, and that inside knowledge of the insurance industry now helps his clients push back against insurers.
Scott joined AP Injury Lawyers in 2026 and handles about 300 cases a year, mainly car crashes.
What Did Scott Learn Defending Claims for Allstate?
Scott learned that a real injury and a fair offer are two different things. Years on the defense side showed him that an insurer won’t volunteer a fair value for a legitimate injury, even when the medical records are clear.
That’s the part that surprises most of his clients. Scott’s answer is to document each client’s story in enough detail that it, in his words, “cannot simply be brushed aside.”
| Detail | Scott Caldwell |
|---|---|
| Title | Trial Attorney |
| Years of practice | 20 |
| Law school | J.D., University of Oklahoma College of Law, 2000 |
| Bar admission | Oklahoma |
| Prior practice | About 10 years as defense counsel for Allstate |
| Jury trials | More than 10 tried to verdict |
| Focus | Car crashes |
| Joined AP Injury Lawyers | 2026 |
What Did Scott Learn Defending Claims for Allstate?
Scott learned that a real injury and a fair offer are two different things. Years on the defense side showed him that an insurer won’t volunteer a fair value for a legitimate injury, even when the medical records are clear.
That’s the part that surprises most of his clients. Scott’s answer is to document each client’s story in enough detail that it, in his words, “cannot simply be brushed aside.”
Why Does Trial Experience Matter in a Car Crash Case?
An insurer’s offer depends partly on whether it believes the lawyer across the table will actually try the case. Scott has tried more than 10 jury trials to verdict.
Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case is different.
His advice to anyone just injured comes down to two words: “Experience matters.” Oklahoma insurers often argue the injured driver shares part of the blame, and our guide to Oklahoma’s modified comparative negligence rule explains how that argument changes a recovery.
The Cases Scott Handles Most
Most of Scott’s caseload comes from car accidents in Oklahoma City. He is part of the same team that handles the firm’s other Oklahoma personal injury claims.
What Do Clients Experience Working With Scott?
Scott describes the goal plainly. He wants every client to feel they have “someone in their corner who listens to them, communicates honestly with them, and genuinely cares.”
That approach carries through the whole case, from the first meeting to the final decision on an offer.
Scott’s clients can reach him by phone call, text, WhatsApp or video call, and the firm’s policy is to return calls within 24 hours. The firm also handles the property-damage side of a car accident claim at no charge, so clients aren’t left negotiating their own repair bill.
Meetings with Scott can take place at the office, by video or at the client’s home. Documents are signed electronically, which keeps the case moving while a client is still recovering.
Associations and Community
Scott’s professional and volunteer work includes:
- Member, Oklahoma Bar Association
- Volunteer with Budd’s Third, a nonprofit that helps veterans
His work with Budd’s Third keeps him connected to Oklahoma veterans outside the courtroom.
Find Scott On
Scott’s professional profile is listed here:
To talk with Scott about a new case, calling the firm is the quickest route.
Questions About Scott Caldwell
Does Scott Caldwell speak French?
Yes. Scott Caldwell is fluent in French and English, so clients who are more comfortable in French can speak with him directly about their Oklahoma City injury case.
Will my car accident case with Scott Caldwell go to trial?
Most Oklahoma car accident claims settle without a trial, and the decision to accept a settlement always belongs to the client. As a trial attorney, Scott can take a case to a jury if the insurer’s offer doesn’t match the evidence.
What should I bring to my first meeting with Scott Caldwell?
Bring the crash report or report number, photos of the scene and vehicles, your insurance card, any letters from an insurance company and a list of the doctors you’ve seen. Missing items are fine, since AP Injury Lawyers can request records after the meeting.
Put a Trial Lawyer on Your Claim
A free consultation with Scott’s team costs nothing and commits you to nothing, and it tells you where your claim stands before the insurer’s next call.
Call A Personal Injury Lawyer Now: +1 (405) 336-3000, or send the details through our online contact form. Meet the rest of our attorneys on the team page.
Call For A Free Consultation.
Available 24 Hours A Day, 7 Days A Week.
Oklahoma City Office
2248 NW 40th Street
Oklahoma City, OK 73112
Reviews From Our Clients











